Following the acquittal of the main suspect accused of ordering the assassination of Daphne Caruana Galizia, a delegation of MEPs led by Sophie Wilmès visited Valletta on 16 and 17 November.
Members of the Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs travelled to Valletta to examine the effectiveness of the Maltese judicial system and developments regarding the rule of law and European values more broadly, including the anti-corruption framework and media freedom and pluralism.
The delegation met with Prime Minister Robert Abela and several senior members of his government, the Maltese Parliament's Public Accounts Committee, opposition leader Alex Borg, and representatives of the Momentum Party. MEPs also met Attorney General Victoria Buttigieg, Police Commissioner Angelo Gafà, and representatives of the Chamber of Advocates, the Permanent Commission Against Corruption, the Office of the Commissioner for Standards in Public Life, and the Financial Intelligence Analysis Unit. They discussed recent developments with members of Daphne Caruana Galizia's family and representatives of the foundation created in her memory. Round-table discussions were also held with journalists and civil society organisations, including Repubblika, Aditus and Occupy Justice.
Statement
At the end of the visit, the head of the delegation and Chair of the Democracy, Rule of Law and Fundamental Rights Monitoring Group (DRFMG), Sophie WILMÈS (Renew, Belgium), stated: “Nine years after Daphne's assassination, we must ask ourselves a fundamental question: could someone still be killed today for exposing corruption? Would a journalist investigating corruption be better protected? Would credible allegations be properly investigated? And would justice be delivered more swiftly? I fear we are still far from being able to give clear and reassuring answers to all these questions. And these questions go far beyond Daphne's case alone: they concern the rights and freedoms of every Maltese citizen today. Despite long-awaited reforms, including increased resources for the judiciary, police and prosecutors, improved judicial safeguards, the modernisation of judicial procedures, and strengthened rules on media freedom and transparency, the delegation stresses that these reforms on paper must translate into effective prosecutions of corruption, the efficiency of which unfortunately remains sorely lacking.”
Significant challenges nevertheless remain, particularly regarding the current jury system, which needs to be re-evaluated. The European Commission's 2026 Rule of Law Report continues to highlight the length of judicial proceedings, concerns about the effectiveness of investigations into high-level corruption, and the lack of convincing results in terms of final convictions. Further efforts are also needed to strengthen the independence of the judiciary, particularly through a reform of the appointment procedure for the Chief Justice.
MEPs welcome the new safeguards for protecting journalistic sources and for greater clarity on media and public broadcasting ownership, while stressing that the effective implementation of the European Media Freedom Act remains essential. Access to public information, protection against abusive legal proceedings – particularly SLAPP suits at national level – and the safety of journalists remain major concerns.
Regarding the broader reform of the media sector, launched following the publication of the public inquiry report more than five years ago, MEPs did not receive sufficient information to assess its content. Journalists and media organisations, however, clearly expressed their high expectations in this regard.
The DRFMG delegation also calls for strengthened oversight mechanisms and separation of powers. Independent oversight bodies must have the resources needed to carry out their duties effectively. Rules on transparency and conflicts of interest must be reinforced, and civil society and journalists must be genuinely consulted on reforms affecting their rights.
MEPs recall that, five years after its publication, the recommendations of the 2021 independent public inquiry into the assassination of Daphne Caruana Galizia remain wholly or partly unimplemented. That inquiry exposed institutional failings and a climate of impunity in Malta. Its recommendations also build on those of the Venice Commission, GRECO, Moneyval and the European Parliament.
Sophie Wilmès added: “The independent public inquiry marked a turning point. At this stage, we would have hoped that all of its recommendations had been fully implemented. We acknowledge the progress made, but the work remains largely unfinished. This cannot be a mere box-ticking exercise. What matters is providing a comprehensive response to the deep-seated institutional failings in the judicial system, the protection of journalists and the fight against corruption, so as to ensure lasting change rather than reforms that exist only on paper.”
Reflecting on the delegation's meeting with Daphne Caruana Galizia's family and the foundation created in her memory, Sophie Wilmès continued: “Behind every institutional debate and every judicial procedure is a family that has suffered an immense loss and continues, with remarkable determination, to seek truth and justice. There is also a population that must be able to trust its institutions, to know that justice will be served and that the system as a whole works in the public interest. The European Parliament stands by their side. We owe it to Daphne, to her family, to journalists, to civil society, and to all Maltese and European citizens: we must ensure that fundamental rights and the rule of law are genuinely respected in practice.”
The mission concluded with a press conference at Europe House in Valletta.